The verdict

What replaces the green checkmark

Not a number that turns green. An interval that is honest at every moment you look at it, and a stopping recommendation you are actually licensed to follow.

E
checkout-button-copyKeep running
Keep running. This is not a win.
Observed lift
+7.50 pts
Naive p-value
0.0466
Always-valid p-value
0.470
Always-valid interval
−4.99 pts to +19.99 pts
Observations so far
120

Your dashboard turned green here. Run this to full sample and the effect settles at +2.50 pts. There was never anything in this experiment — both arms were generated from the same rate.

E
onboarding-checklistShip it
Stop and ship. Valid early stop.
Observed lift
+3.78 pts
Always-valid p-value
0.0418
Always-valid interval
+0.07 pts to +7.49 pts
Observations used
1560
Fixed-horizon plan
4000 — stopped 61% early

The interval excludes zero under a statistic that is valid for exactly this stopping rule. Stopping here is not a shortcut, it is the method working as designed.

Why not just tell people to stop peeking

Because it has been the standard advice for twenty years and the behaviour has not changed. People check things they care about. The workable fix is to make checking safe rather than to make it forbidden.